• David H. Kinder, ChFC

Disagreeing With "The Oracle of Omaha" is Practically Sacrilegious... but I'm Doing It

Updated: Dec 28, 2019



Warren Buffett claims that if you invested $114 in the first quarter of 1942 in the S&P 500 Index - AND HELD IT - you would have over $400,000 today (1st Quarter 2018).

https://www.yahoo.com/amphtml/finance/news/warren-buffett-says-couldve-turned-114-400000-230140222.html

Let's take a look at those numbers, shall we? First, it's 76 years between 1942 and 2018. Here's the problem: demographics, political change, economic policies... all change the dynamics. It's so easy to look backwards and say "Here, do what I did and you'll be a successful investor."

But when everything changes, and it is changing more rapidly than ever before... we can't rely on old advice like this.

Second, the annual compounded rate of return would've been 11.33% AFTER expenses. It's important to make that distinction because expenses are always a factor when making investment decisions.

Now, Mr. Buffett DID say that big management or brokerage fees would eat up a lot of those returns. He said it as though it's Wall Street's fault for charging what they charge, but the marketplace changes over time.

Even today, you CAN'T invest directly into the S&P 500 Index. It's not possible. Today, the most popular way to invest as closely as possible is in an equity investment called an "Exchange Traded Fund" or "ETF". And they finally got traction going in the mid-90's or so. The SPY fund (the most popular way to "invest in the S&P 500 Index") got its start in 1993. It obviously wasn't around in 1942. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exchange-traded_fund

Mutual funds didn't really 'take off' until the 1950's or so. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutual_fund

That means that back in 1942, you'd have to invest in each INDIVIDUAL STOCK of the S&P 500 index, and trade them out as the S&P 500 index would trade them - each trade having transaction costs. Unless you paid those transaction costs "out of pocket" they would continue to erode against your returns.

Now, I don't know what the average stock trade cost would be back then, but you could bet that it would eat up a LOT of that initial $114 and the ongoing returns since then.

So, what's my point: Some of these articles - even by world-class investors like Mr. Buffett - require a more "in-depth" look to evaluate the truth behind them. I cannot say that I would rival Mr. Warren Buffett's expertise in investing as he is one of the richest men in the world. But some advice articles, like this one, need to be examined more closely for the "holes" in the logic.

Today, there are new ways to get the upside of an underlying stock market index, without the downside risks. Strategies like this help to "lock in" your earnings and create more safety, security, and guarantees in one's total financial life.

David H. Kinder | Lifetime Tax & Wealth Educator

Dynamic Advanced Insurance, Financial, and Retirement Strategies

3578 Atchison Circle
Riverside, CA  92503-5166 

Phone & Text: 

951.313.8208

Regulatory Disclosure:

David H. Kinder, ChFC® is regulated by the California Department of Insurance as a life, accident & health insurance agent (CA Insurance License #0E54187)​.  This communication is strictly intended for individuals residing in the state(s) of CA. No offers may be made or accepted from any resident outside the specific states referenced until proper state insurance licensing and company appointments are secured for that given state. David Kinder Insurance and Financial Solutions is the marketing name for David H. Kinder, ChFC® and is not affiliated with any other company.  Insurance and annuity product guarantees are backed by the financial strength and claims-paying ability of the issuing company. Guarantees do not apply to the performance of any particular index option on fixed indexed insurance contracts, or on projected dividends on participating insurance contracts.  Not all recommendations necessarily require insurance product purchases. Not all products are appropriate or available for all situations. Results are not guaranteed and are subject to individual situations and circumstances. Listing company client access links under the "Client Access" menu does not constitute any endorsement, filing, or approval of this website or its content by such listed companies.  Client access links are provided for client convenience only.

Not Legal, Tax, or Securities Investment Advice:

The material discussed on this web site is meant for general illustration and/or informational purposes only and it is not to be construed as tax, legal, or investment advice, nor does it represent any specific company or specific products.  David H. Kinder, ChFC® is not registered nor licensed as a Registered Investment Advisory Firm (RIA), Investment Advisor Representative (IAR), nor as a Registered Representative (RR) with any broker/dealer firm, and is therefore not registered with, or supervised by, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), or any state securities regulatory office.  As such, David H. Kinder, ChFC® does not provide investment advice, specifically: buying, selling, holding, risk analysis, or any other analysis of securities, nor the asset allocation of securities portfolios. For specific investment advice on your securities investment portfolio, please contact a licensed and registered investment professional in your state.

He does offer general investment information for educational purposes and may propose alternative financial strategies that do not contain or include securities. He does also discuss the pros and cons of various kinds of accounts (such as IRS Regulated Retirement Plans) and is considered incidental advice surrounding various strategies and solutions, but does not necessarily constitute advice on the underlying securities.  

For tax or legal services and advice, please consult a licensed professional in your state.  Although the information has been gathered from sources believed to be reliable, please note that individual situations can vary and the information should be relied upon only when coordinated with individual professional advice.

The ChFC® is the property of The American College of Financial Services, which reserves sole rights to its use, and is used by permission.  

© David Kinder Insurance and Financial Solutions; All Rights Reserved

Privacy Policy